Originally Posted by
TiasTreasures
I'm interested in this thread and trying to learn something because I have a few antique pieces that may or may not be "fine jewelry". They're not listed yet (maybe never will be).
It does seem that what is needed is a "universal way" to define the different categories. Perhaps if we got more detailed definitions, we can find something that works everywhere.
When does an item qualify as "solid gold"? I just looked it up on Google. 10 K is only 10 parts gold and 14 parts other metals, less than half. So does that mean it's not solid gold? To be 100% gold, it would have to be 24K and that's never done because it would be too soft. Is there a dividing line?
Does "mined gems" include semi-precious stones, such as turquoise, jade, amber, and many others, where the value varies tremendously based on the quality of the individual stone? Do they qualify if they're set in sterling, gold, platinum or rhodium?
I think everyone agrees that manufactured stones (such as CZ's) and plated metal do not belong in fine jewelry. However, it appears that there is then a difference in terminology. If "costume jewelry" is only used in the US, don't we need to find other terms that would be understandable everywhere?
Maybe take another look at Ideal's suggestions, and try to go forward from those categories?
Jewelry-> High End, Fine Gold & Silver, Rare Gems
Jewelry -> Gold, Silver, Cubic Zirconia
Jewelry -> Pewter, Plated, Beads
Jewelry-> Hand Made
Jewelry -> Everyday Wear, Costume, Imitation