I do agree with your way of thinking as another point of view, which is why we have these forums so that the pros and cons can be weighed up.
I would like to just clarify that I dont think that an item should just be removed or price lowered. I just think having a watchers list is another tool for a seller, especially when listing a new type of item or if you are a new seller and dont know how a sight works or the type of buyers you get on a particular site.
For example, if I list a new item and there are little or no watchers (or views) and I only post to UK, I might consider postage to other destinations.
If I list a new item and didnt include certain specifics in the title, and there were little or no watchers, I would include more detailed descriptions to see if this helped.
With regards to my previous selling experience. I used several different avenues, not just online, but do have my own website too. I have elected not to import my feedback from other sites as I dont think importing feedback helps me (and this is a personal opinion only) on this site. I think potential buyers want to see how good I as a seller on this site and not how I did elsewhere. When I first joined this site I wondered why so many had imported there feedback, for me it was a possible indication that the seller was no longer selling on other sites as they may have been kicked off. Obviously I now know that alot of sellers here were, like me, not happy with the stupidly high fees on other sites but as I was not familiar with the site (and there are many out there like me) it did worry me.
To have a watchers list or not??? I think there are pros and cons and if each were listed I wonder if it would be about even? I think that maybe it should be an optional addition and each seller then can decide if the think its beneficial themselves.
Have a great day!!!!